Matt Nathanson

I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)

• (Meat Loaf cover)

Map at the Mall

Faster

• (With snippet of "Kiss" by Prince at the end)

Adrenaline

• (With snippet of "Edge of Seventeen" by Stevie Nicks.)

Curve of the Earth

• (From album, "Beneath These Fireworks," which was landed on by the Wheel of Song.)

Modern Love

Pablo Picasso

Sway

Run

• (From album, "Modern Love," which was landed on by the Wheel of Song.)

Answering Machine

• (Landed on by the Wheel of Song.)

Kiss Quick

• (From album, "Modern Love," which was chosen by audience.)

Used to Be

Footloose

• (Kenny Loggins cover)
• (Snippet)

Against All Odds (Take a Look at Me Now)

• (Phil Collins cover)
• (Snippet)

Car Crash

Me Anymore

• (From selection Un-sung Heroes," which was landed on by the Wheel of Song.)

Giants

Vampires

Suspended

Come On Get Higher

• (With Snippet of "Defying Gravity" from Wicked Musical.)